Aria Melanie on the LakeModern Mediterranean Cuisine

240 W Main St, Bay Shore, NY 11706

Our MenuAntipasti

Appetizers / Small Plates

Soup du Jour Market
Chef’s daily soup selection
Duck Leg Confit Cassoulet $16
Crispy duck leg, flageolet bean stew, diced lardons
Fritto Misto $14
Fried calamari, shrimp, scallions, zucchini, honey chipotle sauce
Trittico di Bruschette $14
Eggplant and robiola, salmon, cucumber, honey, truffle burrata
Baked Clams Oreganato $12
Parsley, bacon, bread crumbs, Parmigiano Reggiano
Jumbo Shrimp Cocktail $15
Carpaccio di Tonno $15
Yellow tail tuna, avocado, cherry tomato, orange emulsion
Arancini Aria $13
Rice balls with Porcini mushrooms, risotto, gruyere fondue, truffle salt
Beef Carpaccio* $14
Black peppercorn crusted Filet Mignon, arugula, lemon aioli, pecorino
Imported Truffle Burrata $16
Naan crostini, sundried tomato battuto, pickled fennel & onions
A Selection of Artisanal Cheeses $14
Chef selection

Diverse MenuCreative Cuisine

Chef Fabrizio prepares exquisite dishes daily

Our MenuPrimi

Pasta Course

Tagliolini ai Funghi $22
Tagliolini, wild mushrooms, speck, creamy truffle sauce
Pappardelle Allo Zafferano $22
House made saffron pappardelle, sausage ragu, fennel mirepoix, pecorino
Gnocchi $18
Homemade potato gnocchi, pancetta, mushrooms, caramelized onions, creamy truffle sauce
Paccheri alla Norma $20
Eggplant, ricotta salata, marinara sauce
Penne $16
Traditional marinara sauce

Lifeis a combination

of magic and pasta

Our MenuSecondi


Half Roasted Chicken $26
Creamy mustard sauce, caramelized onions, herb oil
Bacon Wrapped Filet Mignon* $42
Thyme red wine reduction sauce, truffle butter
Short Ribs $32
Slow cooked braised beef short ribs, risotto
Cowboy Ribeye* $42
22 oz Cowboy cut, country herb oil, demi-glace
Roasted Herb-Crusted Pork Tenderloin $28
Country herbs, prune balsamic glaze, spinach, fingerling potatoe
Salmon* $30
Pan seared, chick peas curry stew, spiced almond
Pistachio Crusted Tuna* $30
Avocado mousse, soy sauce
Shrimp all’Aglio $32
Colossal shrimp, garlic, fregola, spinach
Specialty Seasonal Fish en Papillote Market
Chef’s choice seasonal fish steamed in parchment paper, sauce americaine

Cookingis like love

It should be entered into with abandon or not at all

Dine on the LakeAt Aria Melanie

240 W Main St, Bay Shore, NY 11706

ReservationsReady to join us?


Open Tuesday - Sunday

You have Successfully Subscribed!